ANAHEIM, Calif. (WGNS) – Eagleville’s own Mattie Pruitt wrapped up her inspiring American Idol journey on Sunday night (May 11), finishing just shy of the Top 5 of Season 23 — an extraordinary accomplishment for the recently turned 16-year-old rising star.

Mattie, the youngest contestant this season, delivered a string of emotional and vocally powerful performances throughout the competition that won over judges and viewers alike. Her standout renditions of songs like Miranda Lambert’s "The House That Built Me" and her heartfelt Mother’s Day tribute last week showed maturity far beyond her years.

Although she fell just short of advancing to the Top 5, Mattie’s run has left a lasting impact on both American Idol fans and her hometown community of Eagleville. Social media lit up following Sunday’s results, with fans across the country praising her composure, talent, and bright future. Locally, support for Mattie never wavered — from handmade posters at Eagleville School to cheering watch parties across Rutherford County.

Throughout her time on the show, Mattie consistently stayed true to her roots, often giving shoutouts to her home in Eagleville and her family’s unwavering support. Her humility and authenticity made her a fan favorite not just in Middle Tennessee, but nationwide.

In an emotional farewell on Sunday night, Mattie thanked her fans, the judges, and fellow contestants. “This has been a dream come true,” she said. “And it’s just the beginning.”

Industry insiders agree — while her Idol journey may have ended, Mattie’s music career is only getting started. With her talent, stage presence, and rapidly growing fan base, many expect big things from this small-town singer.

WGNS Radio has followed Mattie’s journey closely, and while this chapter may be closing, it’s clear that her musical story is just beginning. With a voice well beyond her years and the heart of a hometown hero, Mattie Pruitt is bound for bigger stages and brighter spotlights.

From everyone at WGNS and across Rutherford County — congratulations, Mattie. You’ve made us proud.